Mumbai: Fresh PIL challenges COVID-19 vaccine mandate for local train travel; HC seeks Maharashtra Govt's reply

This is a fresh PIL on the issue and the earlier one was disposed of by the HC at beginning of this month.

PTIUpdated: Monday, March 14, 2022, 07:16 PM IST
article-image
Mumbai: Fresh PIL challenges COVID-19 vaccine mandate for local train travel; HC seeks Maharashtra Govt's reply | Photo: Representative Image

The Bombay High Court on Monday directed the Maharashtra government to file a reply to a PIL that challenged the state's decision to continue insisting that one must be fully vaccinated against COVID-19 to travel in suburban trains and use other modes of public transport in the metropolis.

The public interest litigation (PIL), filed by one Firoze Mithiborwala through advocate Nilesh Ojha, challenged a circular dated March 1, 2022, that was issued by the Maharashtra government to list out the standard operating procedures and safety measures citizens must follow in view of the COVID-19 pandemic. The restriction on public transport, including local trains, for the unvaccinated, was included in the circular.

This is a fresh PIL on the issue and the earlier one was disposed of by the HC at beginning of this month.

Mithiborwala said in his PIL that such a restriction was arbitrary, unconstitutional and an "indirect attempt" on the Maharashtra government's part to make vaccination compulsory.

"The impugned order (circular) is against the state's own policy decision and an indirect attempt to make vaccination compulsory. (Imposing) such indirect compulsion is prohibited by the Supreme Court," the plea reads.

The plea further claims that the state government's insistence on citizens wearing face masks to cover their mouth and nose while out of their homes, and in public places, was "unscientific." The PIL urged the HC to quash the circular.

It also urged the court to direct state and municipal authorities to return the money collected so far from citizens as fine for not wearing face masks in public places.

Ojha mentioned the PIL on Monday before a bench of Chief Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice MS Karnik, and sought an urgent hearing.

The court then directed the state government to file its reply within a week.

Earlier this month, the HC had disposed of a PIL seeking similar reliefs after the state government submitted that despite the court's reservations against prohibiting the unvaccinated from travelling in local trains, it will continue to persist with the restriction.

At the time, the HC had said such a prohibition seemed to have been imposed without any application of mind. However, the court had not passed any orders at the time and had allowed the petitioner to file a fresh PIL challenging the new (March 1) circular.

(To receive our E-paper on whatsapp daily, please click here. To receive it on Telegram, please click here. We permit sharing of the paper's PDF on WhatsApp and other social media platforms.)

RECENT STORIES

Mumbai: Gunshots fired outside Gazebo Shopping Centre on Linking Road in Bandra

Mumbai: Gunshots fired outside Gazebo Shopping Centre on Linking Road in Bandra

Mumbai updates: Traffic snarls halt city ahead of long weekend

Mumbai updates: Traffic snarls halt city ahead of long weekend

Mumbai: Cancer Patients Rest House gets inhouse Laundry at Byculla Railway Hospital

Mumbai: Cancer Patients Rest House gets inhouse Laundry at Byculla Railway Hospital

Independence Day 2022: Western Railway to organise exhibition on 'Partition Horrors Rememberence...

Independence Day 2022: Western Railway to organise exhibition on 'Partition Horrors Rememberence...

Mumbai: Director of pvt firm held by CGST in Rs 27.59 cr ITC fraud

Mumbai: Director of pvt firm held by CGST in Rs 27.59 cr ITC fraud