Senior lawyer Harish Salve has called for a thorough investigation into US short seller Hindenburg Research's report that led to market volatility last month, dragged down by Adani group firms that the short seller targeted.
Putting politics aside for a moment, Salve claimed that "Hindenburg is no Good Samaritan" and that the situation has a "completely different dimension," namely the desire to profit from the suffering of the middle-class investor.
Hindenburg is no Good Samaritan
"There is a completely different dimension to this. Hindenburg is no Good Samaritan who has exposed wrongdoing. They have timed the report, they have dropped the report. They do it for shorting," Salve told NDTV on Friday.
"It is my suggestion - I have said this publicly and I am repeating that - the committee must find out all those who have made tonnes of money at the cost of the middle class investor by shorting shares," he said, referring to a six-member committee set up by the Supreme Court to investigate the Adani group-Hindenburg row.
"Treat that as market manipulation and get them to disgorge and ban them from trading. We must set an example in our market - that first of all if there is a report, it must go to SEBI, it must go to the Serious Fraud Office, it must go to the Ministry of Corporate Affairs - they will investigate and deal with such matters," Salve said as per an NDTV report.
SEBI to probe issue
"But if you are going to use reports like this to attack companies, the SEBI will not sit quiet. They will go after the people who are exploiting market volatility, who have moneybags, exploiting volatility, hitting the middle class investor," he said.
"India is new at this game. We are growing our capital markets. The middle class investor is petrified that every time he lists in a company, tomorrow if there is another Hindenburg report - by the time it is proved to be false, it is too late, your shares have tanked anyway. We must have some institutional mechanism to say that the people who are making money off this misfortune of the middleclass shareholders are held to account," Salve said.
Adani-Hindenburg row committee
Salve, welcoming the formation of the committee, said the Adani-Hindenburg row involves some complex financial matters that only subject matter experts can handle.
"The JPC (joint parliamentary committee) consists of MPs who are very wise people. Here, what has happened is in an area - a very specialised field. What has happened here is there are allegations made on structuring of companies, allegations made about how shares have been issued, how shares have been overvalued, how the market has been played," Salve said as per the NDTV report.
The six members of the committee are former Supreme Court judge Justice AM Sapre, former SBI chairman OP Bhat, retired Bombay High Court judge Justice JP Devadhar, former Infosys chairman KV Kamat, Infosys co-founder Nandan Nilekani and lawyer Somasekharan Sundaresan, who is also a securities and regulatory expert.
Salve said it is "critical" for the investigation to be done in a time-bound manner as investors' confidence is fragile.
