'Removed From Reality': Supreme Court Schools Sharmila Tagore On Stray Dogs

'Removed From Reality': Supreme Court Schools Sharmila Tagore On Stray Dogs

The Supreme Court on Friday criticised actor Sharmila Tagore’s submissions on dealing with stray dogs, calling them “completely removed from reality.” Hearing a case on the stray dog menace, the bench said dogs roaming in hospital premises could pose serious health risks. The court also rejected proposals like colour-coded collars to identify biting dogs.

Shashank NairUpdated: Friday, January 09, 2026, 07:54 PM IST
article-image

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday described actor Sharmila Tagore’s arguments to dealing with the stray dog menace as "completely removed from reality." A bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath, Sandeep Mehta and NV Anjaria was hearing the matter.

During the hearing, counsel appearing for Tagore, an applicant in the stray dog case, cited the example of “Goldie”, a friendly dog that has reportedly lived on the AIIMS premises for years, to argue that not all strays pose a danger. The bench, however, came down heavily on the submission.

"You are completely removed from reality. Don't try to glorify these dogs in hospitals," the Supreme Court said. "Was she being taken to the hospital theatre also? Any dog that’s in the streets is bound to have ticks. And a dog with ticks in a hospital will have disastrous consequences. Do you understand?" the bench said.

The Supreme Court also rejected a proposal to introduce colour-coded collars to identify dogs that had bitten people, a practice followed in countries such as Georgia and Armenia. “What is the population of those countries? Please be realistic,” the bench said.

The apex court was informed on Thursday that removing dogs from public spaces could cost the government up to Rs 26,800 crore.

For the past two days, the matter has been heard extensively, with the bench primarily examining the issue of stray dogs in institutional premises.

RECENT STORIES

Gujarat: PM Modi & German Chancellor Friedrich Merz Attend International Kite Festival In Ahmedabad;...

Gujarat: PM Modi & German Chancellor Friedrich Merz Attend International Kite Festival In Ahmedabad;...

'PSLV-C62 Mission Witnesses Disturbance At PS3 Stage, Deviation In Vehicle's Flight Path': ISRO

'PSLV-C62 Mission Witnesses Disturbance At PS3 Stage, Deviation In Vehicle's Flight Path': ISRO

'Freezing Cold': Gurgaon Outskirts Turn Frosty At –1°C; Viral Video Shows Frost On Fields &...

'Freezing Cold': Gurgaon Outskirts Turn Frosty At –1°C; Viral Video Shows Frost On Fields &...

ISRO’s PSLV-C62 Lifts Off With Earth Observation Satellite, 14 Other Payloads In 1st Mission Of...

ISRO’s PSLV-C62 Lifts Off With Earth Observation Satellite, 14 Other Payloads In 1st Mission Of...

West Bengal: Major Fire Breaks Out At Bagha Jatin Railway Station; Local Train Services Disrupted

West Bengal: Major Fire Breaks Out At Bagha Jatin Railway Station; Local Train Services Disrupted