Haryana: Supreme Court directs state govt to reinstate 1300 primary school teachers

The issue started in 2012 when the State of Haryana issued an advertisement for 9780 posts for primary school teachers. An essential qualification per the said advertisement was the Haryana Teacher Eligibility Test (HTET) qualification.

ANIUpdated: Thursday, September 15, 2022, 08:15 PM IST
article-image
Teacher/ Representative Photo |

New Delhi: In long-drawn litigation spanning over 10 years, the Supreme Court finally ended the controversy between competing candidates for Primary School Teachers by directing the State to accommodate them.

The issue started in 2012 when the State of Haryana issued an advertisement for 9780 posts for primary school teachers. An essential qualification per the said advertisement was the Haryana Teacher Eligibility Test (HTET) qualification. However, the State did not conduct the said test until 2013. However, the State later clarified that the 2013 test was HTET 2012. This led to litigation between candidates who cleared HTET before 2012 (First List) and those who cleared 2013 (Second List). The first judgment came in Antim Kumari Vs. the State of Haryana in 2015, whereby the State acknowledged the right of the candidates who passed the HTET in 2013. However, once a combined merit list was prepared according to an interim order of the High Court in May 2017, the qualifying number of candidates exceeded the vacancies, thereby leading to the First List candidates being removed in favour of the more deserving candidates of the Second List.

Finally, the High Court decided the petitions on merits on July 20, 2022, whereby the claim of the Second List candidates was entirely set aside. The Second List candidates challenged this in the Supreme Court.

"The Supreme Court has passed an extremely magnanimous order, doing justice to all the teachers involved who have been going back and forth for almost ten years. At the heart of this order is the consideration that the education of young students should not suffer. The Supreme Court heard the matter for nearly two hours and even discharged its board for the day, showing that its only priority was putting this long-drawn litigation to rest, " said Somesh Tiwari, Managing Partner, Vardharma Chambers

"I extend the heartiest congratulations to the litigation team of Advocates Kartika S. Sharma, Shashank Bajpai, Kaveesh Nair, Vidula Mehrotra" added Somesh Tiwari.

The Bench of Hon'ble Justices Aniruddha Bose and Vikram Nath heard the petition filed by Vardharma Chambers. The team from Vardharma Chambers, comprising Advocates Shashank Bajpai, Somesh Tiwari, Kartika Sharma, Vidula Mehrotra, and Kaveesh Nair, was led by Senior Advocate Mukul Rohatgi. In addition, a connected petition by similarly placed candidates was filed, led by Senior Advocate PS Patwalia. Advocate Shreeyash U. Lalit also represented similarly placed candidates.

After thoroughly appreciating the matter, the Bench exercised its powers under Article 142 and directed the State to accommodate all the teachers. The Bench was mindful of the State's support for the candidates and the vacuum of qualified teachers.

(To receive our E-paper on whatsapp daily, please click here. To receive it on Telegram, please click here. We permit sharing of the paper's PDF on WhatsApp and other social media platforms.)

RECENT STORIES

NMC scheme not popular as Ukraine returnee Indian students worry about costs, year back, and more

NMC scheme not popular as Ukraine returnee Indian students worry about costs, year back, and more

UGC asks institutions to appoint compliance officers for international students

UGC asks institutions to appoint compliance officers for international students

Studying in UK? ICICI Bank announces bank accounts for Indian students; learn how to activate

Studying in UK? ICICI Bank announces bank accounts for Indian students; learn how to activate

IIT Madras starts Subra Suresh Distinguished Lecture Series, to be lectured by Nobel Prize awardees

IIT Madras starts Subra Suresh Distinguished Lecture Series, to be lectured by Nobel Prize awardees

ICAR AIEEA UG 2022: 8 candidates score a perfect 100 in exam

ICAR AIEEA UG 2022: 8 candidates score a perfect 100 in exam