In its ruling on Thursday, the Supreme Court stated that merit cannot be reduced to the definition of performance in an open competitive examination, and it must be contextualized in social terms.
The Court also said that open competitive examinations only provide formal equality of opportunities. These observations are part of a detailed order passed by the Supreme Court in the matter concerning the pleas relating to providing 27 percent reservation for Other Backward Class (OBC) and 10 percent for Economically Weaker Section (EWS) category in the All-India Quota (AIQ) seats for the admission in the NEET for all medical seats.
A Bench headed by Justice DY Chandrachud observed while passing its detailed order on upholding the 27 percent quota for Other Backward Classes (OBC) in National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) All India Quota (AIQ) seats. The top court also said that examinations are not a proxy for merit and merit should be socially contextualized and re-conceptualized as an institution towards equality that we as a society value. "Reservation is not at odds with merit but furthers its distributive impact," the top court said.
The Supreme court also clarified that the Central Government was not required to seek the permission of the Court to reserve seats in All India Quota. On January 7 the Supreme Court allowed NEET-PG Counselling for 2021-2022 based on existing EWS/OBC reservation criteria. The apex court had given a green signal to 27 percent reservation for Other Backward Class (OBC) and 10 percent for Economically Weaker Section (EWS) category in the All-India Quota (AIQ) seats for the admission process in the NEET as existing criteria this year.
However, for the EWS category, the Supreme Court had said that the 10 percent criteria, which was notified earlier shall continue to operate for this year so that the admissions process shall not be dislocated for the current academic year. The Court had said that it will hear the matter relating to EWS later and listed it for the third week in March. The Court had noted that there is an urgent need to commence the process of counseling and therefore it issued some interim direction.
The Court has earlier reserved its order on pleas relating to providing 27 percent reservation for Other Backward Class (OBC) and 10 percent for Economically Weaker Section (EWS) category in the All-India Quota (AIQ) seats for the admission in the NEET for all medical seats. On December 31, the Centre filed an affidavit stating that it has decided to stick to the existing criteria of Rs 8 lakh annual income limit for determination of 10 percent EWS reservation concerning the ongoing admissions to the NEET postgraduate courses.
The Centre had informed the apex court that an expert committee constituted by the government to reassess the criteria, suggested that the existing criteria may be continued for ongoing admissions while the revised criteria suggested by the Committee may be adopted from the next admission cycle. Changing the EWS criteria midway will lead to complications, the Committee had opined while recommending the introduction of revised EWS criteria from the next academic year.
