A former Chief Justices of India may be as gullible as common man

A former Chief Justices of India may be as gullible as common man

Chief Justices of India — present and past— continue to be in the news for the wrong reasons. The latest is an episode where the 41st CJI Rajendra Mal Lodha was duped by an online cheat who hacked into the account of another Supreme Court judge

FPJ BureauUpdated: Thursday, June 06, 2019, 10:48 PM IST
A former Chief Justices of India may be as gullible as common man

Chief Justices of India — present and past— continue to be in the news for the wrong reasons. The latest is an episode where the 41st CJI Rajendra Mal Lodha was duped by an online cheat who hacked into the account of another Supreme Court judge, Bisheswar Prasad Singh, and requested Justice Lodha to send Rs 1 lakh to the account of his surgeon as his cousin was suffering from acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (a type of fast-growing blood cancer). These fraudulent emails which clog our inboxes are ignored by everybody which makes it surprising that a former CJI could fall for such a ruse.

Both the 41st CJI R M Lodha and his friend, Justice B P Singh, are scions of judges. Justice Lodha’s father was a judge and Justice Singh is the grandson of the 6th CJI Bhuwaneshwar Prasad Sinha and his father, Rameshwar Prasad Singh was a judge of the Patna high court.

Since judges beget judges like doctors beget doctors, the collegium of the Supreme Court occasionally elevates those with illustrious judicial pedigrees to the high courts and, not infrequently, to the Supreme Court. Perhaps this may be one reason why law minister Ravi Shankar Prasad has said that his ministry “is not a post office and will set up an all-India judicial service commission to select judges for the subordinate judiciary.” Today, those aspiring to become magistrates or district judges must sit for a judicial service exam followed by an interview conducted by the chief justice and senior judges of that state high court.

And in a separate development, Justice Ananga Kumar Patnaik - who was asked to probe the allegation of framing of CJI Ranjan Gogoi in April this year by a former woman staffer because of the nexus between corporate bigwigs, the underworld and Supreme Court employees - has asked the CBI, the IB and the Delhi Police to furnish more documents to help him ferret out the truth about bench-fixing and cherry-picking judges for favourable orders. The good judge needs more time to cull out the truth.

A Chandigarh lawyer settled in Delhi, Utsav Bains, claimed he was offered Rs 1.5 crore to represent the woman staffer and hold a press conference in Delhi and also do “lawyering” (sic), whatever that might mean, which implies Bains’ command over the English language leaves much to be desired.

So, the victim in the sexual harassment case may now claim to have become victimised after her charge of sexual harassment against Justice Gogoi backfired. Very sad. The truth, or whatever is left of it, will allegedly come out after Justice Patnaik submits his report to the apex court in a sealed cover after two months. It is doubtful if the media will have access to this fascinating report.

But to return to the 41st CJI Lodha, the judge fell for the bogus email and sent Rs 1 lakh to the so-called surgeon’s account because he could not contact Justice Singh over the phone. What is surprising is this former CJI did not verify whether the email was genuine or not by sending an emissary to Justice Singh’s office, if the latter was not available over the phone.

Judges’ minds are like sieves, allowing primary evidence to percolate into their judgments and discarding what has not been proved. As every lawyer knows, emails are not admissible as evidence unless accompanied by a certificate under section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 which certifies the email was not tampered with.

Courts do not accept electronic files as evidence unless they are certified as not having been tampered with. This can only be done by the Central Forensic Laboratory at Hyderabad or other government laboratories which examine the files sent to them using scientific techniques before certifying that the emails or other electronic records can be accepted as evidence. Justice Lodha seems to have forgotten this.

And so, what we learn in law school and in the courts is applied in daily life but Justice Lodha may have been an exception despite being a very competent judge of the Bombay high court between 1994 and 2007 before being transferred by the Supreme Court collegium to his parent Rajasthan high court until his elevation to the Supreme Court where he headed the collegium which selected high court and Supreme Court judges. He was fooled by a common cheat because friendship between judges like R.M. Lodha and B P Singh transcends common sense which may not be as common among intellectuals as among common people.

One interesting aspect of his tenure was when controversial Justice Gyan Sudha Misra retired from the Supreme Court in 2014. When she confessed at her farewell function, that the clock was her greatest enemy, the then CJI-designate Lodha used humour to handle the piquant situation because the woman judge had declared her two daughters’ marriages under the liabilities column with her stridhan of a gold set with “few gold rings and a pair of bangles.” This made it to the national newspapers.

Justice Lodha took over from an equally controversial CJI, P Sathasivam who accepted a gubernatorial post in Kerala after he attended the marriage ceremony of BJP chief Amit Shah in Delhi. Of course, this was after Justice Sathasivam retired. But his accepting a gubernatorial post raised eyebrows because a CJI is higher in the pecking order than a governor and by accepting this assignment, it was felt that the former CJI had perhaps devalued the dignity of the CJI’s office.

Be that as it may, the latest episode of former CJI Lodha being taken for a ride reinforces the aphorism that we deify our judges by addressing them as Lordships in courts, because they deal with weighty matters of life and death when subject to the same foibles as the common man. This is why the collegium system of appointing judges has been described as 100 per cent defective by former collegium member Justice Kurien Joseph at a book release function last month.

Justice Joseph deeply regretted backing the majority which struck down the 99th Constitutional amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission to allow the government to have a say in judicial appointments. The judges by a 4 to 1 majority opined that allowing the government to have a say in appointing judges violated the basic structure of the Constitution. Former law minister Arun Jaitley disagreed with this asserting that the framers of the Constitution wanted the government to have a say in who would become a judge.

But Justice Joseph has admitted that it was possible for lawyers to predict the outcome of a judgment depending on the quorum (composition of the bench) and thus judgments can be manipulated by cherry-picking judges to get favourable orders. Using different words, he is admitting what CJI Gogoi has claimed and what Justice Patnaik is probing.

And so, we have to accept that words like “bench-fixing” or “manipulation of orders” or “cherry-picking judges” which were earlier spoken of in whispers in court corridors have now entered unceremoniously into legal vocabulary after being used by the Supreme Court judges themselves. Olav Albuquerque holds a Ph.D in law and is a journalist-cum-lawyer of the Bombay high court.

Olav Albuquerque

The writer holds a PhD in Media Law. He is a journalist-cum-lawyer of the Bombay High Court.