Hijab row: Students contend in Karnataka High Court, ask 'where is the law prohibiting headscarves'

Representative Image | Photo by GOH CHAI HIN / AFP
Bengaluru: A full bench of the Karnataka High Court headed by Chief Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi and comprising Justices Krishna Dixit and JM Khazi Monday adjourned the case regarding the legality of wearing hijab in educational institutions to Tuesday.
The court heard the argument surrounding Article 25 of the Constitution which pertains to freedom of conscience and free profession, practice and propagation of religion. While the petitioners said this gives an absolute right, the court pointed out that the conditional clause should also be read. Article 25 (1) states that it is “subject to public order, morality and health and to the other provisions of this Part, all persons are equally entitled to freedom of conscience and the right freely to profess, practise and propagate religion”.
The petitioners argued that the government order giving colleges the right to decide whether to allow hijabs on campuses is 'totally illegal' as college committees do not have any legal basis.
Senior advocate Devadatt Kamat, representing the Muslim students of Kundapura college, argued that"to allow the College Development Committee to decide whether to allow students to wear headscarves or not is totally illegal. The only restriction that can be imposed under Article 25 is public order, which can only be imposed by the state. Can a college development committee consisting of an MLA and some subordinates decide on exercising fundamental freedom? How can a statutory authority be made the guardian of our fundamental rights?"
To this the court asked the advocate as to what constitutes public order.
Meanwhile, fresh petitions were filed Monday and the court asked the petitioners to submit all their urgent petitions at the appropriate urgent counter section of the court.
The high court will hear the matter again Tuesday.
Earlier Friday, the court passed an interim order asking students not to wear any religious dress to class in educational institutions that have prescribed uniforms.
Meanwhile, after a five-day break to cool communal tensions over the hijab ban row, high schools for up to Class X reopened in Karnataka Monday. Colleges are on holiday till February 16.
As a precautionary measure, prohibitory orders have been imposed near campuses for six days till Saturday in Udupi and Mangaluru. Section 144 of CrPC has been clamped around 200-metre radius of all the high schools from Monday till February 19.
Later, the judge hearing the case, referred it to a larger bench and in a contentious interim order, ruled last week that schools and colleges could reopen but no religious clothing, including hijabs, would be allowed.
A government order last week had left it to colleges to take a call on whether to allow hijab.
Kamat told the bench led by Chief Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi and comprising Justice Krishna S Dixit and Justice JM Khazi that colleges are not competent to take a call on public order and it was the duty of the state to do so. In this case, the state, he said, has abdicated its duty.
Even Kendriya Vidyalayas permit Hijab of same uniform colour, Mr Kamat pointed out. "Kendriya Vidyalayas even today they permit by a notification, that even though they have a uniform, Muslim girls are permitted to wear a headscarf of the uniform colour," he said.
The hearing in the matter will resume tomorrow afternoon, the court said.
ALSO READ
RECENT STORIES
-
Bhopal Water Safety Alert: BMC Shifts 22 Km Of Drinking Water Pipelines Away From Sewers To Prevent... -
Madhya Pradesh's 139 Excellence Schools Next In Line For Sandipani Tag, Merger Proposal To Reach... -
Maheshwar Fort Needs Urgent Repairs, Says Yashwantrao Holkar As Over 20,000 Attend Social Kumbh In... -
UP Govt Plans New Teaching Duties For Teachers Assigned Census & Election Work, B.Ed & BTC Trainees... -
Gorakhpur JCB Incident Claims 14-Year-Old Boy's Life, CM Yogi Adityanath Meets Family As Police Book...
