Supreme Court's 3:2 Verdict: Queer Couples Denied Adoption Rights; Centre To Form Committee To Look Into Matter

Supreme Court's 3:2 Verdict: Queer Couples Denied Adoption Rights; Centre To Form Committee To Look Into Matter

The five-judge bench delivered a split verdict, with a 3:2 majority opposing adoption rights for LGBTQIA couples.

FPJ Web DeskUpdated: Tuesday, October 17, 2023, 02:03 PM IST
article-image
Same-Sex marriage | Representational Image

The Supreme Court of India ruled on a series of petitions seeking legal recognition for same-sex marriages, with the denial of adoption rights to unmarried queer couples. The five-judge bench delivered a split verdict, with a 3:2 majority opposing adoption rights for LGBTQIA couples.

Chandrachud & Kaul argued in favour of adoption rights

Chief Justice DY Chandrachud and Justice Sanjay Kaul maintained that adoption rights should be extended to queer couples, highlighting the discriminatory nature of existing adoption regulations against them. They argued that the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA) circular, which currently restricts adoption by queer couples, violates Article 15 of the Constitution.

Justice Chandrachud emphasized that CARA Regulation 5(3) indirectly perpetuates discrimination against non-traditional unions and stressed that there is no substantive evidence to support the notion that only a married heterosexual couple can provide stability to a child.

A committee to be set up to look into the matter

As a result of the ruling, the central government is set to establish a committee tasked with determining the rights and entitlements of individuals in queer unions. This committee's responsibilities will include considering the inclusion of queer couples as a family unit on ration cards, allowing them to nominate for joint bank accounts, and extending rights related to pensions and gratuity.

Furthermore, the court underscored that central and state governments, as well as Union Territories, must refrain from discriminating against the rights of the queer community to form unions. This historic decision has far-reaching implications for the legal recognition and rights of same-sex couples in India.

RECENT STORIES

Congress' K C Venugopal Alleges Modi Govt Targeted His Phone With Spyware, Vows To Oppose...

Congress' K C Venugopal Alleges Modi Govt Targeted His Phone With Spyware, Vows To Oppose...

Nagaland State Lottery Result: July 13, 2024, 1 PM Live - Watch Streaming Of Winners List Of Dear...

Nagaland State Lottery Result: July 13, 2024, 1 PM Live - Watch Streaming Of Winners List Of Dear...

Nagaland State Lottery Result: July 13, 2024, 4 PM Live - Watch Streaming Of Winners List Of Dear 50...

Nagaland State Lottery Result: July 13, 2024, 4 PM Live - Watch Streaming Of Winners List Of Dear 50...

Kerala Lottery Result: July 13, 2024 - Karunya KR-662 Live! Saturday's Draw Reveals Winners Of...

Kerala Lottery Result: July 13, 2024 - Karunya KR-662 Live! Saturday's Draw Reveals Winners Of...

Himachal Pradesh: BJP's Ashish Sharma wins Hamirpur Assembly By-Polls By Margin Of 1,571 Votes

Himachal Pradesh: BJP's Ashish Sharma wins Hamirpur Assembly By-Polls By Margin Of 1,571 Votes