It all started with MCI case

FPJ BureauUpdated: Thursday, May 30, 2019, 12:53 AM IST
article-image

New Delhi : The Medical Council of India case was the first sign that all is not well in the apex court. It witnessed a headlong collision between Chief Justice Misra and Justice Chelameswar. The case came before the apex court in November through a PIL seeking an SIT probe by a retired CJI.

Admitting the petition, Justice Chelameswar ordered setting up a constitution bench of five senior most judges for hearing the petition. But before Justice Chelameswar could pass the written order, another draft order was delivered to him by CJI Misra who posted the matter before another bench. Meanwhile, the petitioner contended that CJI Misra should not be on the bench hearing the PIL seeking the SIT probe. Justice Chelameswar refused to pass an order on this stating that the constitution bench would decide the matter on November 13.

On the other hand, the CJI set up a seven-judge constitution bench on November 10 – a day after Justice Chelameswar ordered setting up a constitution bench to hear the PIL seeking SIT probe – to examine the ruling passed by the second senior most judge.

Two of the judges of the constitution bench recused themselves. The other five judges, including CJI Misra, annulled the order passed by Justice Chelameswar setting up the constitution bench. The presiding bench ruled that setting up a constitution bench falls under the administrative power of the CJI.

(To receive our E-paper on whatsapp daily, please click here. To receive it on Telegram, please click here. We permit sharing of the paper's PDF on WhatsApp and other social media platforms.)

RECENT STORIES

Bhagat Singh death anniversary: 7 movies based on the life of Bhagat Singh

Bhagat Singh death anniversary: 7 movies based on the life of Bhagat Singh

10 shayari by Mirza Ghalib that beautifully captures the pain of love, life and heartbreak

10 shayari by Mirza Ghalib that beautifully captures the pain of love, life and heartbreak

Teachers' Day 2021: Wishes, greetings in Hindi, Marathi to share on SMS, WhatsApp, Facebook and...

Teachers' Day 2021: Wishes, greetings in Hindi, Marathi to share on SMS, WhatsApp, Facebook and...

Meet Akhil Poddar young head of Rajasthan-based Poddar Group of Industries who inspires people to...

Meet Akhil Poddar young head of Rajasthan-based Poddar Group of Industries who inspires people to...

Nirjala Ekadashi: Things to keep in mind about the rituals and celebration

Nirjala Ekadashi: Things to keep in mind about the rituals and celebration