Will Scotland secede from UK?

Will Scotland secede from UK?

FPJ BureauUpdated: Saturday, June 01, 2019, 08:58 AM IST
article-image

On September 18, a remarkable event will take place in Great Britain, that would be a shock to the world. On that date a referendum will take place on whether Scotland should be an independent country of Great Britain.  Acceptance of this concept had been arrived at following an agreement between the Scottish Government and the United Kingdom on November 14, 2013. The agreement  received Royal Assent a month later on December 17, 2013. As recommended by the British Election Commission, the referendum question will be: “Should Scotland be an independent country?” Large sections of educated people all over the world would probably be surprised to know that Scotland and England were united to form the Kingdom of Great Britain way back in 1707. Prior to this, Scotland was an independent country for over 800 years. Now, almost three centuries later, Scotland wants to be independent. Sponsoring the separation is the Scottish National Party (SNP) which became the largest party in the Scottish Parliament in the 2007 polls. Why on earth the Scots want to be “free” is anybody’s guess.

What on earth has pushed Scots to seek independence when all these decades they were part and parcel of Great Britain which built up an Empire over which it was said the sun never set? Weren’t the Scots equally guilty of conquering free nations all over the world and looting their wealth as they did in India? Recent polls organised by the Scottish Daily Mail early in August showed that 50 per cent of respondents planned to vote against independence. By contrast, just 37 per cent said they planned to vote for a split, while 13 per cent said they were undecided. Excluding undecided voters, support for independence stood at 43 per cent against 57 per cent in favour of the union. Unless there is a “seismic change” for all purposes, the United Kingdom will not break and will remain what it has been: United. But nobody is taking the newspaper poll for granted. Moreover, is 43 per cent a “small minority?” Will it take a United Kingdom as unchallengeable? Some people think that a newspaper poll cannot possibly be taken as truly representative of people’s feelings.

  The people have two options: one, vote to stay within the Union. The other, vote for separation. In the end, one has only to wait and see. Anything is possible. Of course, one doesn’t expect the separatists to take recourse to violence whichever way the wind is blowing. To resort to violence would be barbaric and very un-British. But suppose the separatists win, even by a small margin or for that matter lose, similarly by a small margin? What is likely to happen? What would be the consequences? If Great Britain accepts separation – can we call it partition? Will it not be the end of its Greatness? On what grounds can a partitioned have the right to be a Permanent Member of the UN Security Council? If it refuses to quit, what would be the next step the United Nations may be forced to take? Besides, if Britain were to be dispossessed of its rank, would Russia have the right to stay on, considering that the Soviet Union ceased to exist a long while ago? There are many such questions that will inevitably arise which need to be faced.

Again, will a separate Scotland accept the Queen as the head of State? What would the currency note look like? The principal options are to establish an independent Scottish currency, or join the European Union’s single currency, the Euro or retain the Pound Sterling. According to information presently available, the SNP favours continued use of the Pound Sterling through a formal currency union with the United Kingdom and the Bank of England setting interest rates and laying down monetary policy with the latter acting as Scotland’s Central Bank. The current belief seems to be that a currency union would be in both Scotland and the United Kingdom’s interests, immediately post-Independence.

The UK is – and can remain – Scotland’s main trading partner primarily because both have a “relatively high degree of economic synchronicity.” Scotland’s main export to the UK will be the North Sea oil, considering that the oil fields are located in Scottish territorial waters. As the current Scottish Government sees it, a currency union would save business in England, Wales and Northern Ireland £ 500 million in transaction costs while trading with Scotland. The SNP advocates that an independent Scotland should have a relationship with the European Union similar to that which the UK has today, with the European body. So many issues will have to be resolved if an independent Scotland comes into existence. Scotland may have to open up as many as a hundred embassies around the world. It will have to create a new flag in place of the Union Jack. It will also need to have a new national anthem to replace ‘God Save Our Gracious Queen’: One understands that the SNP is in favour of retaining the monarchy by a personal union with the rest of the UK – whatever that means. If one does not have one’s own national anthem, what is the point in having an independent state?

 But what comes through as a tragedy is that the Scots want to be emotionally dissociated from the Anglican and the Welsh. What was the necessity for separation? Does the Battle of Banockburn still haunt the Scots? In what way will the Scots improve their standard of living following partition? But even that, surely cannot be a good reason for demanding the country’s partition? The separatists are quoted as saying that “control of welfare policy would be a major benefit of independence.” One can only feel sorry for the Separatists when globalisation is the order of the day. Or is it that the Gods are seeking revenge on Great Britain for partitioning India way back in 1947? There can never be any knowing what history is up to. How one wishes Winston Spencer Churchill was alive to see what history has done or is going to do for his own country.

M V Kamath

RECENT STORIES

Editorial: Need To Look After The Aged

Editorial: Need To Look After The Aged

Analysis: Anonymous Electoral Bonds Reined In — But What About Anonymous Cash Donations?

Analysis: Anonymous Electoral Bonds Reined In — But What About Anonymous Cash Donations?

Editorial: Government Cannot Be Run From Jail

Editorial: Government Cannot Be Run From Jail

Decentralisation Can Build Better Cities

Decentralisation Can Build Better Cities

Analysis: Elections Are The True Test Of Democracy

Analysis: Elections Are The True Test Of Democracy